Two companies of Huntingdon County men marched out in the summer of 1861 with the Fifth Pennsylvania Reserves, and the county can now be told what became of the regiment, with the book it comes from.
The Fifth Reserve, numbered the Thirty-fourth of the Pennsylvania line, was organised at Camp Curtin in Harrisburg on 20 June 1861 out of companies raised in Lycoming, Northumberland, Clearfield, Union, Huntingdon, Centre, Bradford and Lancaster counties. Huntingdon County furnished two of them: the Huntingdon Infantry under Captain Andrew S. Harrison, which became Company G, and the Scott Infantry under Captain George Dare, which became Company I.
Now the count, which this page has been carrying a note about for some time. William F. Fox set the regiment's losses out in 1889 in the standard book on the subject, and lists it among the three hundred fighting regiments of the war. Of 1,046 men enrolled, 14 officers and 127 men were killed or died of wounds, which Fox works out as 141 killed, 13.5 per cent of the regiment. Another 68 died of disease, accident or in prison. Two hundred and nine in all.
An earlier version of this post gave those same figures and then concluded that more men died of dysentery, pneumonia and typhoid than of Confederate bullets. That part was wrong, and it was wrong against its own numbers: 141 is more than twice 68. In this regiment the fighting killed twice as many as the sickness did.
The two Huntingdon County officers named above were both killed. George Dare rose from captain of the Scott Infantry to major, then to lieutenant colonel, and was killed at the Wilderness while in command of the regiment. Frank Zentmyer, who took over Dare's company when Dare was promoted, was killed at Fredericksburg, where the regiment lost 18 killed, 87 wounded and 61 missing, and where Fox notes that the missing were all killed or wounded. Colonel Seneca G. Simmons had been killed at Glendale two years earlier while commanding the brigade.
Fox lists the fights where the regiment lost men: Mechanicsville, Gaines's Mill, Glendale, Manassas, South Mountain, Antietam, Fredericksburg, Bristoe Station, the Wilderness and Spotsylvania. It was present also at Malvern Hill, Gettysburg, Mine Run, the North Anna and Totopotomoy.
If you have a soldier from the Fifth Reserves in your family, tell us his name and his company and we will look him up properly.
Checked against the record. THE COUNT IS BACK, BECAUSE IT WAS RIGHT ALL ALONG, AND TAKING IT OUT WAS THIS SITE'S MISTAKE RATHER THAN THE ORIGINAL POST'S. That is worth saying plainly.
An earlier check found that the post's closing sentence contradicted its own arithmetic: it gave 14 officers and 127 enlisted men lost to combat, 68 to disease, and then said disease had killed more. It caught that correctly. But it then removed the whole casualt…
Sources
- Regimental Losses in the American Civil War, 1861-1865, page 256: the loss table for the Fifth Pennsylvania Reserves (34th Pennsylvania Infantry), in the chapter on the Three Hundred Fighting Regiments, William F. Fox (Albany Publishing Company) (1889)
- History of Huntingdon and Blair Counties, Pennsylvania, 1883: “The Fifth Reserve, or Thirty-fourth Regiment”, naming the two Huntingdon County companies, their captains, and the regiment's organisation at Camp Curtin, J. Simpson Africa (Louis H. Everts, Philadelphia)
Read the full story, with 3 passages quoted from the county histories →